• Back to Project

Comments for Milonic DHTML Website Menu

Re: license

> The "free for non-commercial use"

> statement is wholly misleading. All you

> get is crippleware. A waste of time.

Care to elaborate? Or are you just bitching for the sake of it?

license
The "free for non-commercial use" statement is wholly misleading. All you get is crippleware. A waste of time.

Re: Free ?

> Completely free (even for commercial

> use) set of DHTML menus ! [BSD license]

>

> freshmeat.net/projects...

Thanks very much for advertising your menu system on someone elses comments section, very noble of you.

Regards

Andy

Re: must compliment your baptizising

> my next project will definitely be named

> byronic <something>. i don't have

> any need for your miltonian menu atm,

> but, i'll definitely use it at the first

> sign of applicability.

Great News!!!

I look forward to it.

Thanks Very Much

Andy.

Free ?
Completely free (even for commercial use) set of DHTML menus ! [BSD license]

freshmeat.net/projects... (freshmeat.net/projects...)

must compliment your baptizising
my next project will definitely be named byronic <something>. i don't have any need for your miltonian menu atm, but, i'll definitely use it at the first sign of applicability.

Re: NOT GPLED

>
>
> You failed the read the bit about
> "temporarily removed the downloads",
> they will be back up at the weekend.

No, I didn't fail to read anything. I also managed to read your custom license agreement at www.milonic.com/licens... (www.milonic.com/licens...)
which without a doubt places restrictions on the software.

By withholding free downloads and restricting distribution to only those who purchase a license makes it commercial. IMHO you should have suspended downloads to everyone to avoid any confusion.

Once you do restore free downloads it seems the license for this project -- based on the license link on the site as well as the required registration -- should at least be Free to use but restricted.

Re: NOT GPLED

>
> % Well it looks like you'll have to
> change the license to "Commercial"
> % now.
>
>
>
>
> Ok, done.
>
>
>
> Thanks,
> Jeff
>

You failed the read the bit about "temporarily removed the downloads", they will be back up at the weekend.

Re: NOT GPLED

> Well it looks like you'll have to change the license to "Commercial"
> now.

Ok, done.

Thanks,

Jeff

Re: NOT GPLED

> Thanks; I've updated the listing.
>

Well it looks like you'll have to change the license to "Commercial" now.

This text comec from www.milonic.com/downlo... (www.milonic.com/downlo...)

Due to the recent high demand for the menu we have had to cease offering free downloads for the time being.

In order to download the menu you will need to purchase a license from www.milonic.com/cbuy.php

So either they have had hundreds of thousands of downloads or this is their best excuse for changing the terms of the license.